Friday, January 25, 2008
New year: Starting from scratch
When a blog begins a post with a title like “Starting from scratch” one might expect I’m going to announce some big change in the way I live my life, or at the very least, a re-design of the site. But not this life, not this blog. I’m talking about my music collection and the way I maintain it. Specifically, I’m talking about why I never really liked my iPod and why I’m glad I replaced it with an iRiver Clix.
Several years ago, when I heard there were car radios that could play MP3 CDs, I started saving all my music in this format thinking I would one day own such a stereo. Then came portable MP3 players and the iPod. I resisted for a while, but finally bought an iPod when the fifth generation Video iPod was released.
The task before me now was daunting: How do I fill a 60 gig iPod using a 30 gig laptop? It took weeks to offload small batches of music from CDs and CD-ROMs, make sure they were properly tagged, move them to my iPod, delete them from my computer, and start again. I had a major setback when my iPod froze while being “ejected” from the Mac I used at work. This resulted in a corrupted database on the iPod. Many of the songs were simply missing, some songs played at the same time over the top of each other.
Even in the first few days of use, I’d already noticed the ways Apple’s iPod was not a perfect fit for me or my expectations. No FM tuner (radio) was a big annoyance and should have kept me from buying the iPod in the first place. I listen to public radio a lot. I knew from day one with the iPod that if I ever replaced it, I would have to find something that came with a radio. Second, the iPod is not hot-swappable. I have to plug it in, wait for the computer to recognize it, start up iTunes (Oh, no. Can’t use your iPod with anyone else’s software.), transfer the songs, click to eject, wait for the computer and the iPod to say farewell, stand around awkwardly for a bit, each of them not sure what else should be said, give each other one last embrace, and as they separate, the iPod allows his hands to trail down the computers arms and take hold of her hands, then slowly, slowly but finally, let go. And please, please don’t freeze up.
In the end, I gave up when my iPod was a little more than half full. If I got new music, I’d put it on there, but I never attempted to archive my music on the iPod again.
After I moved to California and had the ability to listen to KCRW while driving, I started using my iPod less and less. But two or three months ago I decided the iPod and I needed to reacquaint ourselves … and I just couldn’t find it anywhere. I really did make an honest effort to find it, but in my heart I was glad to have the opportunity to replace it with something better.
I started researching. I found a great resource called Anything But iPod that helped me narrow down my choices with its thorough MP3 player comparisons and reviews. In the end I settled on the iRiver Clix (second generation). Here’s why:
- FM radio
- Hot swappable. This is great for several reasons. I can use it like a USB thumb drive: plug it in, transfer files, unplug it, and go. I can view all my music files in non-hidden, properly named folders. I can drag music from the Clix directly to my computer or any computer I want. I can drag music from my computer directly to the Clix. I don’t have to use an iTunes-like media player if I don’t want to.
- It can play several different audio types, whereas the iPod can only play two. It plays a few different video types, whereas my iPod would only play one, and not a very common one at that.
- It has a voice recorder, and can record the FM radio. I can even schedule recordings with the timer.
There’s one thing the iPod does right, and that’s the click-wheel. It just doesn’t get simpler or more easy to use than that. While I don’t mind the Clix’s interface, it takes just a little bit more work to do what you want. But the Clix more than makes up for this by doing so much more than the iPod.
So, I knew that I would never make the most of the Clix if my music remained on CDs and CD-ROMs. So I purchased an external hard drive that is now the home of all my music and photos. It’s pretty excellent to have everything right at my fingertips.
Archiving it was still an ordeal because many of the CD-ROMs I made in the early years did not make use of proper tagging, so the artist, title, album and other relevant information was often missing or had been filled in incorrectly. The last time I tried archiving my music, I filled in the missing information by hand, searching Amazon or the Internet for the correct titles. This time, it’s been a much simpler process thanks to a program called Media Monkey, a music jukebox player and organizer. It’s 100 times better than iTunes for many reasons, but one feature alone made me love it forever. I can highlight the songs in an album and look it up on Amazon. Media Monkey will automatically fill in any missing or incorrect data based on Amazon’s database. It even stores the album art in the id3 tag. Seriously an amazing piece of software. Check it out.
(2)
